(Season 1, Epi­sode 9; Airdate: 3/11/71)
When their crowded stagecoach is held up and Heyes and Curry recognize one of the robbers, they wonder if the man also recognized them. While the travelers are stopped at a way station, the gang sneaks onto the land and surprises station master Charlie Utley (played by Keenan Wynn) in the barn, with the offer of a deal to give him money in exchange for two of his customers — who they expose as the wanted outlaws Heyes and Curry. The quick-thinking old man agrees, takes the money and then double-crosses the robbers once he gets back inside the station, figuring he might as well get the reward if anyone is going to. Randolph Mantooth, of later Emergency fame, guest-stars as a protective young husband and father.